Blain’s Late Morning Porridge June 3rd 2025 – UK Strategic Defence Review has massive market consequences
“The supreme Art of War is to subdue the enemy without fighting.”
Yesterday, the UK unveiled its long-awaited Strategic Defence Review. The implications for markets, both for Bonds and Equity, and the cohesion of the West are massive. The SDR represents an opportunity and challenge.
Rhetorical Question:
- Would you buy the bonds of a nation securing its future through a carefully considered and costed defence programme?
- Or would you gamble on a nation freeriding off its allies, taking a punt that conflict with “peer nations” is unlikely, which deliberately degrades its armed forces to focus spending on other “public goods” like welfare and infrastructure?
Most politicians would agree defence is the primary role of the state. Investors would likely concur – there are substantial risks in funding a successful but lightly defended economy if it’s likely to be steamrollered by the hostile aggressive kleptocracy from over its Eastern border. And not just conquered, but seeing its industry and commerce downgraded by cyber-attacks, its digital infrastructure nullified by littoral sabotage, and its morale and cohesiveness undermined by fake news and hacks.
As Sun Tzu sagely observed the most effective defence is to deter enemies from attacking in the first place. Any nation that deliberately downgrades it military capability in the face of increasing threats – which should include carelessly and rudely unravelling long-established alliances – should be considered as a potential political risk by debt investors.
In recent months trade-off between security and cost has become frighteningly clear to Europe. The continent has woken up to the need to take responsibility for its’ own defence in the face of an America-First driven Donald Trump. The fracture in NATO has emboldened our enemies as much as Trump’s failure to acknowledge or stop Russian aggression.
There is a growing understanding in Europe that NATO – with or without America – is still the strongest guarantor of European Security. Stand together and Europe will endure. Stand apart and its nations will likely fall one by one.
The Germans see it – the need to defend themselves. They have decided to rip up the holy writ of their debt rules to finance a massive rearmament programme – seeking for defence spending to surpass 3.5% of GDP.
Yet, the UK gives the impression of a literal rabbit caught in the debt headlights – Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer refusing to be drawn on when the UK will actually reach 3% of GDP except that it will be during the next parliament – “circumstances permitting”. That is a bit weaselly. Already there is much talk about how much taxes will have to rise to pay for a relatively modest increase in spending to 2.5% by 2027.
Yet, the idea that global debt investors might regard a higher debt quantum to fund the urgent defence of the UK as the actions of a prudent and competent government has apparently not been considered. The UK Treasury is still in shock from the Liz Truss lesson on government incompetency and markets 3 years ago – impressing its caution on Chancellor Reeves with demands for budget constraint.
The reality is the need for defence spending is a “special case”. Were the UK to ask bond markets to fund higher defence spending – they would likely approve it. Preserving the UK not only would ensure the prompt repayment of interest and principal on Gilts (which is all bond investors truly care about), but ensure other investments into equities and private markets in the UK were also insured against foreign agression.
Equity markets have already seen spectacular gains from the rearmament of Europe. The defence primes such as BAE, Rheinmetall and Babcock have all posted meaningful gains in recent months. There is surging interest in the emerging DefTech sector – where new weaponry is being innovated by SMEs and Start-Ups. Notions that ethical investing meant no to defence stocks have been largely abandoned. Defence is now seen as sustainable in the wider sense of the expression.
To be fair, you can understand Starmer’s reticence to spend money on defence. The trick is not spending money, but knowing what to spend it on. Senior military officers like nothing more than bigger budgets to buy lots of new kit – like setting children loose in a sweet shop.
The UK’s defence procurement record is shocking. While completing my masters in economics I wrote my dissertation on the reasons for the repeated failure of UK defence procurement. That was back in the 1980s. My conclusions then were expectations creep, a lack of clarity on what the kit was required to do, poor project management, constant modifications and redefinition added to cost and delay. The stifling bureaucracy enabled defence contractors to avoid responsibility. Has much has really changed today? Ask the army about their Ajax armoured reccy vehicles.
Listen to the generals and they will tell you the next conflict threat in Europe is only 2-3 years down the road. Russia has embarrassed itself tactically in Ukraine squandering enormous amounts of material and manpower for limited gains against the more nimble and better led Ukrainians. However, Putin runs a Dictatorship in full Wartime Economy mode – able to replace lost kit and field new conscript armies.
According to former UK Chief of the Defence Staff, Lord Dannatt, on the BattleLines podcast y’day they could be able to test NATO, perhaps in the Baltic, within 2 years. That’s the timeline for Starmer to be able field a “warfighting” UK force to deter Russian aggression.
To be brutally frank it’s unlikely the UK will be able to defend itself in 2 years time.
Today, the immediately available defence of the UK boils down to around 5 available frigates, maybe a couple of submarines, and some 30 fast jet fighters and a couple of dozen tanks. One of the Big Targets Aircraft Carriers is off swanking the South China seas. The other is being “overhauled”. That’s pretty pathetic for the fifth highest spending military power. At present the UK would struggle to counter Russian littoral assaults on marine infrastructure like fibre-optic cables, energy platforms and ports, or defend UK cities from hypersonic missile and drone assaults such as Kiev faces nightly.
The reality is to deter aggression – which is better than winning a war – the UK needs to be part of a strong European alliance: NATO or its successor. There will need to be specialisation – for instance the UK is unmatched in special forces. Let others – perhaps the Ukrainians with their mastery of drones – take responsibility for other aspects of the modern battlespace.
To be clear, the UK should never find itself fighting Russia alone. We will be deterring Russia as part of a strong Europe/NATO. We’d like for the Americans to be involved.
There were headlines in the wake of the SDR that made me laugh. The FT: “Britain to build up to 12 attack submarines as it moves to war-ready footing”. Brilliant. They aren’t even designed yet – in fact we are still completing the 7 Astute class subs the new ones will replace. If we wait for these new subs, the war will have been over for around 10-years. War-ready means fighting a war now – not in the late 2030s.
The trick is not how much money is spent, but how well it is spent. Where should the UK be spending money? That’s why the big Defence Prime Contractors have benefited from the expectation of massive defence spending programmes building new ships, planes, tanks, guns and lots of war stocks like missiles and shells – all stuff the forces need.
However, there are lots of lessons to be learnt from current global conflicts. A few include:
- The USA has dropped more very expensive bombs, and fired even more expensive missiles at a faster “cadence” (a word the military love) on Houthi Rebels in Yemen than at any time in their previous history. For what? Blowing up desert? The Houthis dust themselves off and keep sinking ships with cheap as chips drone tech. Boots on the ground would have sent them scurrying.
- The war in Ukraine has taught multiple lessons on how quickly DefTech is evolving – everyone is aware of the criticality of Drone warfare capability, although fewer understand how swiftly electronic and kinetic countermeasures are evolving. Drones work well in static 1914-18 era trench lines, but would need a rethink in a war of manoeuvrer.
- Even more interesting was the recent snap conflict between Pakistan and India, where the Pakistani’s shot down a surprising number of modern Indian aircraft, using the latest long-range Chinese air-to-air missiles, effectively “sniping” the Indians from the air before they were able to get into range to use their (now obsolete) western weaponry.
- Gaza has demonstrated how effectively the Isreali’s are able to defend their tanks from close-range, man-carried anti-tank missile attacks through radar/lidar turret systems able to take out any and all kinetic attacks. This kind of vehicle defence tech could result in a renewal of mass manoeuvre tank warfare (The Ukrainians are experimenting with the tech on the battlefield today.)
The nature of warfare is constantly evolving. The UK SDR came a day after Ukraine’s spectacular Operation Spider-Web of coordinated drone strikes on Russian strategic aviation assets. Apparently, the Ukrainians took out 30% plus of the long-range bomber force. The videos show burning elderly Tu-95 Bears, but other kills include at least one A-50 Mainstay Battlefield Management early warning plane – a very high value military asset worth millions taken out by a $700 drone. (This was at least the third Mainstay the Ukrainians have destroyed.)
There is much kerfuffle the attacks will precipitate a massive retaliatory strike by Russia, but the reality is Putin knows he walks a narrow line as her strings Trump along. If he over-reacts, then Trump’s displeasure and the threat of well supported new US “Senator Graham” sanctions would kick in.
The reality is the Ukrainians are showing they are adaptable, nimbler and now that Europe and the USA have effectively removed range parameters from how their weapons are used the Blue Team is punching well above its weight. All the aircraft destroyed in the attacks will have been used by the Russians to launch missile wave attacks on Ukraine – fair targets.
Defence analysts will be talking for years about the attack – how the drones were smuggled inside the ring of electronic blocking countermeasures assumed to be defending Russian bases, and how they were coordinated. Not since the early SAS took our Luftwaffe bases in North Africa in 1942/3 have some many high value targets been removed from the board. If anything it confirms the failure of Russian Tactical Doctrines to adapt to the wiley Ukrainians. Slava Ukraine!
What does the future look like following the UK strategic defence review? There is much to question – how money will be raised, how to budget it, how to restore morale in the Armed Forces (hence the focus on better accommodation) and how to make them an attractive career option, and what to spend money on.
But long-term a strongly defended nation as part of a strong and functional NATO should give our enemies pause. And defence spending will not only boost the economy, but make the debt profile stronger.
Out of time and back to the day job…
Bill Blain
Author of the Morning Porridge
Founder and CEO of Windshift Capital
Partner Shard Capital
2 Comments
Comments are closed.


Excellent article. The bond market angle is something that the Treasury should understand. But behind the rhetoric there is the strong impression the government’s heart really isn’t behind this review if it means very tough decisions on tax rises or welfare cuts or both.
I think there is a lot of fear – for instance; what does debt service costing more than defence mean about the sustainability of the debt, or that the declining demand for Treasuries is fatal. On their own these things can be dealt with. Even an interest rate spike would be bearable… but and but again, we have the added issues of the end of the dollar era, Trump, Trump and Trump. Political brinksmanship/incompetency and a sustainable treasury market sit uneasy.