Blain’s Morning Porridge 9th January 2025: The Bond Bear Market – Get Used to It!
“When bonds yield 400 bp over stocks is when you realise you missed the sell signal.”
UK Chancellor Rachel Reeves is being blamed for the Gilt Bear market. Harsh and unfair – it’s a global thing. Investors fear sticky inflation as much as rising debt quantums, tax cuts and spending plans. A global bond bear market brings consequences – be aware of them.
Just in case you hadn’t noticed, we are deep into a Global Bond Bear Market. The 30-year bull market from 1981 is so over! We are in full bear mode – get used to it. That’s a problem as the Bond Market is the Schleswig-Holstein Question of the markets – incredibly complex and inter-connected across relative value asset markets; yet understood by few. As Lord Palmerston said in the 1860s: “Only three people have ever really understood the Schleswig-Holstein business, the Prince Consort, who is dead, a German professor, who has gone mad, and I, who have quite forgotten all about it.“
It’s been so long since we’ve had a proper bond bear market, few folk have much recollection or understanding of what it means. They ought to learn quickly. To put it in context – when the bond market shifts – all assets eventually adjust and pay attention.
One of the great investment myths is that markets are smart and clever with instantaneous understanding of events. They are not. Major changes in the market environment aren’t immediately understood and spotted – sometimes the relevance of an inflection point isn’t grasped for years! A bond bear market will impact stocks – at its simplest, why buy dividend yields at 1% when the US Treasury will pay you 5%? If yields rise – so will defaults. Bond yields will impact currency markets, and thus trade, growth and recession/boom.
Bonds matter.
One of my market theories is the concept of Virtuous Sovereign Trinity: that a nation with a strong currency, a sustainable bond market, and competent politics will do well. It will be able to raise money on the bond markets and sustain growth. However, where the theory struggles is when the competency of politics comes under extreme pressure – which is pretty much what we are seeing across the Western World at present. Political populists and the right are blitzkreiging incumbent governments to an extent unparalleled in financial history. Government trying to do the right thing are buried in extraneous noise – like here in the UK where the noise around grooming gangs fuelled by misinformation and Musk tweets has stymied serious debate on the economy and growth. The result is despond and crashing confidence in the future. How do we get past it? Difficult.
Long-term Morning Porridge readers will be aware I reckon the current fantabulous valuations across stock markets remain grossly inflated due to the ultra-low interest rates of 2009-2022. Low rates fuelled speculation– a period of normalised, higher, real interest rates (when interest rates are higher than underlying inflation), tends to do much to quell investment insanity.
This morning the crypto-shills are out in force advising the purchase of Bitcoin because the current bond “rout” spells the end of fiat money…. Au contraire I say: normalised interest rates will quell speculation, and are just as likely to crush the fervid rise in crypto. History shows conventional currencies cope: the last big bond bear market lasted 30 years and saw US rates rise from 2% in 1950 to 16% in 1981 – high rates spelt difficulty, but not the end of the world.
There is a gloop of ignorance and politically polarised nonsense around rising bond yields – as an example; take a look at the comments on a perfectly innocuous article in the FT this morning “UK 10-year borrowing costs hit highest level since 2008”. There are over 1000 comments and 90% of them are ignorant, ill-informed politically motived diatribes aiming to score cheap non-sensical points against Chancellor Rachel Reeves and the UK government. Curiously… very few of the comments talked about inflation – the main, but not only, reason bond markets lie on the edge of turmoil.
Let’s be clear: the bond bear market is a global phenomenon brought on by normalised interest rates, inflation fears and valid investor concerns about debt quantums:
- Global investors are fearful President Donald Trump will slash taxes and raise borrowing thus destabilising the balance between demand, supply and confidence in the Treasury market.
- They are nervous about dither in the UK – where confidence has been knocked by an overly cautious new government, rising taxes have impacted growth and spending cuts now threaten to plunge the economy into stagnation, or even stagflation!
- They are shocked at the political instability now apparent in France and Germany – and how that will be reflected in bond prices. French bonds now trade at a discount to Greece! Moody’s are warning of a vicious feedback loop from higher deficits, higher costs and higher debt. And Europe is unprepared for a debt crisis.
All bond markets are concerned at stubborn, stickly inflation and how that will impact their bond market investments. That’s why it’s the long-end of the bond market where yields have risen most – where the bonds are most sensitive to inflation and there are fewer buyers. If investors fear inflation is likely to rise – that’s a far bigger problem for bond demand than a government borrowing a couple of billion more to patch a few fiscal holes!
Analysts across the bond market are warning the bond sell-off marks the return of bond vigilantes – bond buyers demanding tighter issuance controls and threatening a buyer strike if yields don’t rise to reflect their concerns. I have met many self-declared “bond vigilantes” during my career, but curiously never seen them demonstrate en-masse, and I’ve never been invited into the smoke-filled rooms where no-doubt they write their demands for fiscal rectitude and austerity spending. That’s because… they really aren’t important. Bond Vigilantes are a convenience to describe why a bear market is taking hold. I have never met a bond investor who has not wanted a higher yield, and rising supply when demand is static – means yields will rise!
Curiously, there is no shortage of demand for bonds. We’ve just seen the strongest opening week in US Corporate Bond market history – despite the fact US defaults are finally showing signs of rising. (January is always the busiest month for bond origination, but it’s clear borrowers want to front load their funding to avoid paying higher rates later this year.) That said, the Chinese, and to a lesser extent, the Japanese are no longer the major buyers of global government bonds they once were – but there is still plenty of demand to go round at the right price.
The reality is the cost of the volume of bonds sold by national debt offices during the QE period, or through the Pandemic, is largely immaterial – most of it was issued at interest rates close to zero. As that debt matures and rolls off debt costs will rise. The UK’s average maturity is around 15 years (the longest of any major nation), meaning (theoretically), were paying zero on much of the outstanding debt.
New debt is more costly, and that’s one of the issues detractors of the new UK government have seized upon. If the cost of servicing the government’s debt load increases, then the government will be forced to borrow more to pay it, or increase taxes, or raid pension pots! Ouch.
The noise being directed against the new Labour government as a result of the rise in Gilt yields is out of all proportion to its significance. It’s politically motivated – not grounded in reality. In today’s torrid politicised markets a rise in rates may be a national disaster, but it’s a gift for opposition politicians to claim Reeves is as bad as Liz the Lettuce Truss.
No. She isn’t.
If Reeves has made mistakes – and who hasn’t – it’s been Labour surfeit of caution, which has become an issue undermining confidence in the UK. Prime Minister Starmer has warned so often about further economic pain to come he may actually have talked the economy into a dip. A little more economic enthusiasm and untying the fiscal straight-jacket ties could help.
If there is a message – it’s keep a closer eye on bond auctions and what they tell us about changing demand for bonds. It’s also important to figure out what portion of global assets will be directed into bonds in the future as the goals of investment continue to change. That’s a massive project for another day.
Out of time and back to the day job..
Bill Blain
Author of The Morning Porridge
3 Comments
Comments are closed.


I’m genuinely intrigued Bill. Why are you giving Rachel Thieves a free pass?
Saying “ooh, not her fault, but maybe untying the fiscal straight jacket might help” seems disingenous at best. She is the one who has tied the bloody thing!
The OBR has summarised her budget as REDUCING growth in both the short and long term compared to previous policy. Ergo our GDP will shrink and our ability to pay back our debts in the end will REDUCE. That is her fault and nobody else’s (in that she embodies New New Labour policy in this area).
Her budget would best be characterised as Tax more, borrow more and spend LESS on the things that might actually generate growth. Shurely any fule kno that this is a recipe for disaster in real terms.
And if she won’t spend now to accumulate later then don’t we have to fix inflation?
There is a simple solution to inflation – it’s all about energy costs. The entire global economy is driven or hamstrung by the cost of energy. We in this country have jumped on the collective western high horse and foregone(*) cheap Russian energy and it is going to kill our economy as sure as eggs are eggs. NB The US doesn’t care about this high horse because it is energy independent (and is selling gas to us at 6 times the Russian price!). They are laughing all the way to the bank as German industry both collapses and moves to the US at the same time. What’s left of our industry will do the same.
Does anyone have the courage to bite that bullet? Sadly I suspect not. But we could at least try to spend our way out of trouble, because the ratcheting up of austerity (which is what is happening NOW!) spells certain doom.
This “government” is making Nero’s leadership look proactive and credible.
So, as someone who loaded up on long duration GILTs last year as “things can only get better”, where should I be going now please?
(*) spoiler alert, we haven’t, we just buy it from India at vastly inflated prices to make us feel better about “fighting Russia to the last Ukrainian”.
Liz Truss was the author of her own destruction. There is a counterfactual underway to paint the emerging sterling/gilts crisis as one that Reeves has constructed. No so – the UK is the victim of past decisions and “events, events, dear boy”. I am begining to fear the seeds of a full blown crisis were sewn years ago and now about to bud. Hard hats to the ready.
Amazing how quickly people have forgotten the trusterf&£c and 15 years of Tory austerity. Lest we forget, the only countries to impose harsher austerity measures than the uk during the GFC were ….Spain and Greece.