Blain’s Morning Porridge Dec 6th 2024: UK Railways represent broken Britain – they will take years to fix. Labour will get the blame.
“The only way to be sure of catching a train is to miss the one before it.”
I feel sorry for Sir Keir Starmer. He’s become the UK’s most hated politician in a remarkably short period of time. It’s apparently all his fault. Labour’s dither illustrates the real crisis at the heart of broken Britain: long-term fixes for incoherent privately-owned infrastructure when short-term politics focus on the immediate here and now.
I wish I’d watched Alistair Campbell on the BBC’s Question Time last night – not just for his verbal jousting with Nigel Farage over Brexit – but more for the silent head shake that said it all when he was asked about Sir Keir Starmer’s relaunch of the Labour Government yesterday. As more than one national newspaper has commented – Labour desperately needs someone like Campbell running comms; pulling the strings and driving the programme to get the message across.
Clear communication of Government policy is critical. When the prime minister, for all his good intentions, lacks charisma to the degree Starmer does – we have a problem. It’s given the Tories and the rest of the opposition opportunities to repeatedly counter-attack, attack and attack – Blitzkrieg Politics undermining every single mission, policy, objective and now 6 new milestone pledges. Labour look permanently on the back foot.
We always knew Labour was going to be forced to make the kind of difficult policy choices the Tories had avoided on spending and revenues. Cutting fuel allowances, widening inheritance taxes, raising the pay of workers and taxing businesses more, were “courageous” calls in “Yes Minister” speak – where courageous means likely to cost votes and an election.
Labour has got zero credit for its efforts – just the opprobrium of the masses.
It’s called politics.
The Tories are proving surprisingly effective at blaming it all on Starmer – but lest we forget, they were in power from 2010 till July this year. The mess the UK economy, infrastructure and services find themselves in did not suddenly occur on July 5th! Nope, to wreck the economy as comprehensively as the one Labour inherited that day.. well that took the combined talents of Dave, Tess, BoJo, She-who-should-be-forgotten, and Rishi (who at least looked a bit embarrassed about the state of the place when he left.)
But now it is Labour’s problem.
They need to tell a better story. Starmer’s government is swimming in a treacle soup of mission plans, goals, objectives and now 6 new milestones. These need to be delivered in a way where the electorate feels change is coming, and they are enthused about it. That is the critical difference between this Labour Government and New Labour under Tony Blair (ably supported by Campbell) in 1997. Blair was exciting and a rocket-ship of promises and hope. Starmer is a good man, and means well – but its increasingly clear he’s failing to communicate that. Frankly, he’s a bit of a plodder.
All of which leads me to my Friday rant… UK Railways – A Rant (again)
Wrecking the UK railways has been a national talent ever since the Stockton and Darlington rail opening in 1825 – the beginning of the railway age. (Did you know the first railway death was a Tory MP at the Rainhill Trials in 1829? Demonstrating the usual sense of his species.. he apparently walked in front of one of the trains competing in the trials to choose the best new engines!) Our national inability to make railways work culminated in the privatisation of Rail in the early 1990s, and government thinking it was now an SEP (someone else’s problem). No. Privatisation of public utilities has been a disaster – most Tories now accept that. I blame, (heresy alert), Thatcher.
I’ve been up in London for a lot of meetings this week. That means… catching the train. I am increasingly convinced that under the Tories there was a Deep State plan to make my life miserable by making the trains so bad. This week’s journeys up and down to London have been a succession of testing nightmares – confirming my theory.
The Labour government is fighting back – on Tuesday they announced the nationalisation of South Western Trains – the first operator to be taken back into state control in an effort to rationalise the dysfunctionality of multiple rail franchises (each effectively a local monopoly) with few incentives to work for the benefit of passengers, or coordinate with the rail-track owner. Over 30 years UK rail privatisation has been an utter disaster.
Sadly, it’s going to take a decade or more to make the UK’s rail system functional again. Nationalising the service might ultimately result in better long-term strategic planning – but the brutal reality is things will get worse, and likely more expensive for put upon commuters before they get better – which will be blamed on the current government, not the one that took the decisions (actually didn’t make decisions) that have make the current service so crap. I suspect I will see my career in financial markets wend to its weary close over the next few years still catching an increasingly decrepit railway up to London most days.
That has economic consequences. The lack of effective national transport infrastructure is one factor behind the Londonification of the UK economy – and why young workers, who can’t afford to work or live in London are giving up in droves – living at home or on benefits. Its why London attracts the bulk of office and business investment. If there were decent train services moving around the nation at sensible affordable prices, then the growth snap-shot of the UK would look very different indeed.
Train services are multiple times more expensive and less effective than they were 40 years ago. Famously, a national newspaper recently showed it costs less to fly to New York than a single train ticket from Manchester to London! Privatisation solved nothing – except a few franchise holders made some money, and the bank-owned railway leasing firms made off like butchers’ dogs with the sausages.
Not that I am one to embrace conspiracy theory – BUT! I think the increasing farce that are UK trains (and other aspects of state infrastructure like water and sewerage) reveal a fiendishly clever long-term sleeper strategy to win the Tories an election in about 10-15 years. It’s really simple – their utter neglect of the economy while in office was designed to achieve 2 objectives:
- First, they correctly foresaw Labour would bore the electorate senseless by whining and blaming them for everything….
- Second, they ensured the economy is beyond fixing over the life of any government.
The railways are example of the plan in action. Long-term decisions taken years ago, ensure the railways can’t work properly today.
Let me illustrate:
- Over the past few months SouthWestern trains have introduced “new” 9 carriage trains on the system. They are crazy. The front 4 carriages are local trains with 3×2 seating with no tables, and seat too small even for hobbits to sit on. The back 5 have human sized seats, but they fill up immediately – so there I no space to work. And the trains carry fewer passengers. The railway is stuck with these ridiculous combos for at least 5 years – in time for the Tories to pin the blame on Labour ahead of the next election, and for Labour to make it marginally better.
- The new(ish) Southwestern trains finally being introduced on my line don’t have a drop down table large enough for a laptop. When I started writing the Porridge 18 years ago there were proper tables, and it took an hour on the single stop Southampton to London express. I could write the Porridge start to finish and post it before reaching Waterloo. Now the trains take 30 mins longer – multiple stops making them standing room only by Basingrad – and there is no way to work on board. It slashes my productivity by 25% every time I travel to London.
- Railway travel between Southampton and London was more regular and faster 75 years ago. It’s another example of why the UK has become a third-world economy. The last 15 years have seen the progressive decay of UK railway infrastructure through political neglect.
- Twice this week I’ve found myself on peak time services (£70 a pop, even with an old-person’s railcard) where instead of 9/10 carriages, they’ve been 5 car services. Standing for an hour and a half in a sweaty train might be a form of hot-yoga exercise… but frankly I can get that for less in a luxury gym.
Labour will attempt to fix, repair and maintain the abused national infrastructure, but its already too far gone. The Tory plan is simple: as things get worse people will mourn for the good old days; when rivers were just polluted by sh*t, when trains were awful but still occasionally ran, when the NHS was still a health service. And remembering the past inperfectly will make them think things were better off under the previous shower. Nope. They were not.
Over the next few years the Railways will continue to decline, a result of decisions made over the last decade. These are not Keir Starmer’s fault – but the muppets that went ahead of him. The goal – of everyone – should be to fix them… but that feels unlikely in the current failing political landscape.
Grrrrr… Rant, rant… rant..
Out of time, have a great weekend and off to do the day job.
Bill Blain
Author of the Morning Porridge, and CEO Windshift Capital
4 Comments
Comments are closed.


Reinforced by this mornings nationwide comms failure.
Bill, the photo at the header of today’s Porridge is the most ironic one I can recall you posting. Smiling people happy to be on a train! I’ve had very little experience with UK trains, my last one being a round trip from London to Cambridge in April of 2012, which was uneventful.
If it is any consolation, most of the Amtrak system in the US has plenty of issues as well.
And yet ironically (love a bit of irony) the world’s most efficient, and best train service, Japans, modelled their system on ……the British. So where did it all go so horribly wrong?!
Sorry, late to the party… A number of points:
1. Sorry to spoil your local story but SWT are not the first operator to be taken back into state control. They have been beaten to this accolade by LNER, Northern Trains, Transport for Wales,
SE Trains (Southeastern), Scotrail, Transpennine Express and Caledonian Sleeper. All of whom are now run by the state in one form or other.
2. As you rightly point out, the people who own the trains have made off like butcher’s dogs. Labour are not proposing to do anything about them so don’t expect any progress in the next 5, 10, take your pick years.
3. The electorate were offered an alternative approach to national infrastructure in 2017 – genuine nationalisation of energy, water, transport, health. Unfortunately the team that offered this were so critically undermined by Smarmer et al in the run-up to that election (Chicken coup etc.) we missed out on that land of milk and honey. Nothing comparable or likely to be even remotely effective is being offered by the current administration. Trebles all round?
4. There is no message. There is no programme. There never was. Read the (empty) manifesto…
5. I am coming to the conclusion that Rishi called the election early to ensure that the UK had another 5 years of “establishment” control under “Labour”. Had he waited until “now” then events might have precipitated the further rise of “extremists” who might have put such “stability” at risk – see France, Germany, Moldova, Rumania… Trebles (and wars) all round?