Blain’s Morning Porridge 5th July 2024: UK Election Special – The real winner was Reform, and that will have massive consequences.

“Populism is not a fad – it’s a peoples’ rebellion against big corporations, the economy, government, the media and the environment.”

Labour got a landslide, but did not win the UK election – the Tories lost it. The result is not what it appears to be…. The real winner was Reform, and that could have massive future consequences for Markets and the UK economy.

Last night a bunch of us gathered in the pub ahead of the UK Election Exit Poll announcement. I asked everyone present to guess the number of predicted Tory seats. The low was 70 and the high an improbable 350. I chose 120 Tory MPs – which was pretty much bang on the money.

This morning it’s all about the Labour Landslide of 410 seats… but that is not the real story or what markets should be watching and considering for the long-term following yesterday’s  election.

  • Labour got 3 times as many seats, but did not win – the Conservatives lost, and lost badly, punished by the electorate.
  • Reform were the real winners – although they only got 4 seats.

The rise of Reform, the UK’s most successful populist party, will be the critical factor to consider in terms of the UK’s future political slant. Addressing the very real concerns of Reform Voters should be at the forefront of all the traditional parties’ thinking and policy decisions ahead of the next election. How do they claim back disaffected populist voters? By addressing their concerns.

The critical moment of the past election was Nigel Farage changing his mind about not standing as an MP and stepping up to lead Reform. It galvanised a tidal surge of populist support, and translated into a massive vote shift away from the Tories. Take a look at the many big-beasts of the Tories who lost their seats last night – in every single case it was votes that went to Reform that slew them.

In many respects the vote for Reform is little different from the right-wing populist shift that has occurred across Europe. But it is not just a short-lived protest vote. The liberal elites have made the mistake of portraying Reform as ill-informed racists. The Tories’ entitled leadership dismissed Farage and his chums as a peasant rabble.

The reality is very different and likely to prove long-lived.

Don’t make the mistake of writing off Reform as solely an anti-immigration party. The real issues, and the reasons it did so well across all the English parliamentary seats is that disaffected Reform voters have:

  1. Lost confidence in the traditional, conventional politicians and party politics.
  2. Are mounting a backlash to all the liberal elite themes of wokery, gender politics, diversity and political correctness – which are utterly irrelevant to them.
  3. They distrust conventional news and media as part of the perceived liberal elite machine, making them fertile targets for fake-news and manipulation. Young angry men are willing to follow role-models like misogynist Andrew Tate. They are susceptible to get-rich-easy scams like meme-stocks and bitcoin.
  4. Although Reform has coalesced around the same themes as right-wing European parties; the perceived immigration threat and distrust of Brussels, their support is very real and much deeper rooted. It stems from multiple frustrations:
    1. For many it’s the lack of opportunity, a sense of economic helplessness, and the soaring cost of living that impacts the poor and disadvantaged, while barely touching the wealthy. In that respect it is no different to Donald Trump’s MAGA which recognised the “Great Divide” in US society between the wealthy and empowered liberal elites and the ignored, decaying small town America.
    2. For others it’s the sense the Conservative Party no longer represents pride in national and Britishness.

I would love to see some analysis of who and what demographics voted for Reform. I suspect the party managers will be shocked at how many young people votes for them – let’s see the data. Had Farage decided not to stand, and focused his energies on supporting Trump (as many expected him to do), then I expect yesterday’s vote would have been a very close run thing.

What happens next will be fascinating – will Reform and the Tories evolve into something new, a party of the right that somehow merges traditional conservative values with the demands for economic betterment and anti-liberal stance of Reform? Or will Reform evolve into a party with a full organisational base and executable policies by the next election?

Watch this space…

Out of time – have a great weekend..

Bill Blain

Author of the Morning Porridge

Wind Shift Capital

www.windshift.capital

6 Comments

  1. Bill Blain July 5, 2024 at 9:37 am

    Comment from Reader:
    “Spot on Bill. This is just the latest “F*ck you” vote we’re seeing. I thought Brexit was it. I thought Trump was it. Maybe this will be it. But until politicians realise they are out of touch with ‘normal’ people who care about very different things to those cocooned in their Westminster/Washington/etc/(I’ll include Holyrood too) bubble, these protest votes will continue… which are not good for any medium-term planning as they are, by their nature, short-term reactionary votes against the mainstream.

  2. Alistair Newton July 5, 2024 at 9:41 am

    You say “Addressing the very real concerns of Reform Voters should be at the forefront of all the traditional parties’ thinking and policy decisions ahead of the next election.” – I believe the new Labour government will need to start addressing these concerns from the very outset. If they don’t then there might well be civil unrest in much less than 5 years.

  3. Bill Blain July 5, 2024 at 10:45 am

    Lots of comments coming in about thin the Labour victory was:
    “Labour 700k fewer votes than 2019 which was their worst result in 100 years..”

    Labour 23k votes per seat
    Cons 57k
    Reform 1mm
    SNP 83k
    Lib Dem 49k
    Sinn Fein 30k
    Green 483k

    “The big question is can Labour deliver? If not the next election will be between a Labour Party on its backfoot, and an empowered rightwing populist Reform (anologous to Le Pen in France), while the rump of centrist Tories (who didn’t defect to Farage) will be squeezed out from the sidelines.”

  4. Bill Blain July 5, 2024 at 10:47 am

    From a Canadian Reader:

    As a Canadian living in the UK, the rollout of the Reform Party here as a political force is not at all unfamiliar. If seeking a potential future direction and outcome for the Reform movement, one would be well served to look back to the late 80s/early 90s in my home country of Canada and note how the scene unfolded:

    – a long in the tooth, past its prime Progressive Conservative Party running the country;
    – no palatable centrist alternatives to absorb a ‘rational’ traditional Tory protest vote, only left leaning options (Liberal and New Democrats);
    – a western Canadian movement started in 1987 called…wait for it…the Reform Party of Canada, led by a charismatic former preacher, Preston Manning;
    – the 1993 election solidified Reform’s power base in the West, but as they had no Eastern presence, they just fell short of occupying Official Opposition party role in Canada;
    – the movement continued to grow, and eventually by 2000 the Reform movement had completely consumed the venerable Conservative Party
    – the two parties merged in 2000 and were renamed the Canadian Alliance…and in 2003, the Reform takeover complete, re-branded as the Conservative Party of Canada. Former Reform MP Stephen Harper became leader of the Alliance in 2002, and Prime Minister in 2006…winning further elections in ‘08 and ‘11, and ruling until 2015.

    I thought that made for an interesting series of observations to share with you, as history often rhymes. Ignore Reform at one’s peril!

  5. Jason Dodd July 5, 2024 at 11:05 am

    Ignore Reform at your peril. You can’t continue to dismiss people who have genuine concerns about immigration as just ‘racist’. It’s not a nuanced enough explanation and after a while, people don’t really care. They care more about the tangible effects they see all about them, on their communities, schools, jobs and salaries, as opposed to being called names. Name calling no longer works: remember Brexit.

    • Bill Blain July 5, 2024 at 12:33 pm

      That sums it up well..

Comments are closed.